"I went to the woods because I wished to life deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived." Henry David Thoreau
I think it is quite admirable that Thoreau went to live in the woods. The solitude that you experience when you are emersed completely in nature I find to be pretty invigorating to be honest. My boyfriend's family has a cabin in the mountains near Raystown Lake and when we go there for a weekend trip I feel completely cut off from the world. I don't get service, so my cellphone is shut off all weekend; there is no interenet connection so the laptop stays at home; there is no cable so no TV; there is no running water, so yes we have to get jugs of water from a stream, shower at a neighbors house, and use an out house (which by the way is TERRIFYING in the dark with the thought of snakes and skunks!). So, needless to say we have to create our own parties, which when in the company of friends is actually pretty awesome. I wish there was running water, but other than that for a weekend trip Raystown is soooo relaxing. You wake up whenever you want, eat what you want, ride fourwheelers, go to the lake, go for a hike, make a fire, and party the night away with great friends. I feel like around here with all of the other ways to entertain yourself going into the woods would not be your first choice, but once you're there it's amazing how fun a deck of cards, four wheelers, a fire pit, and a radio can be. It becomes more about the people you're with than what is on tv, or what is playing in the movie theater, or how much money you're going to spend at the mall. This kind of weekend I feel everyone should experience at least once.
However, a whole year is a different story. Yes watching nature is wonderful; going to the lake is super fun; cooking burgers and hot dogs over a real fire, not a grill, is awesome; partying with no one around but the friends you came with is great. I'd say after a week at most for me this would get boring, I would miss the comfort of my own bed, my friends being a call away, my TV shows, and the horses. The fact that I could only handle this for a week is saying one thing and that's with friends. To be in the woods alone even for a weekend would be horrible to me. I don't really enjoy being along for an extended period of time, and I don't understand what more you can learn alone in the woods as opposed to with friends. What is the significance of complete isolation; human contact is one of our needs as human beings. I would definitely get so lonely, scared, and depressed that I would be miserable even if I did go out and experience nature. I disagree with Thoreau that living in the woods in complete solitude for a year would fulfill you to the point that when you died you would know you lived. Family, friends, nature, horses, work, school: all of these things do create some stress, however, they make life worth living. When all is said and done I want to die knowing that I did the best that I could at everything I attempted, that I made a difference in the lives of those closest to me, and that I experienced every situation I desired.
If I spent a year alone in the woods I think I would walk away from it feeling accomplished because I don't know if I could do it, but more so that I wasted a year being alone as opposed to being with those that I love.